What Is a Consultant?

In a tough job market, I’m often the recipient of calls on the subject of Consulting. Is it an option? What’s it like? I am empathetic. I was in the same place many years ago. So now is as good a time as any to share what being a Consultant is, and what it isn’t.

It’s NOT a Lifestyle Choice
Consulting is NOT a lifestyle choice. It’s not a means to have more free time for friends, family or hobbies. Ideally, you will be working for multiple clients, in various time zones, each with a discrete project with separate milestones and deliverables. If anything, it will be more time consuming than a full-time job at a single client.

Evaluate the Demand and Carve Out Your Niche
The more specific you can be about your area of expertise, the better. It helps focus your prospecting and clearly demonstrates value to your potential customers. For me, Sales and Ad Operations was and still is an area with high demand for expertise. Others lean on Programmatic and now AI.

Become Your Client’s Employee
You should think about your client’s business as if it were your own. Are they doing what needs to be done? What can you do to help them achieve their goals? Can your expertise and experience identify risks that your client is not aware of? Thinking about these issues and deciding how to act on them is part of the Consultant’s job.

It’s All About the Deliverable(s)
Each engagement should be defined by an explicit SOW with clear deliverables, down to the type of documentation delivered. IMHO documentation should be in your own words. Your voice and whatever analytical and writing skills you have are your own. I understand the value of AI, but in this case, if you are using AI to prepare deliverables to a client, they can rightfully ask, “why do I need you at all if I can use AI to achieve the same results”.

Don’t Nickel and Dime Your Client.
In my experience, determining a fixed fee and sticking with it has led to numerous clients and renewed engagements over the years. It’s your job as a Consultant to estimate the time and effort needed for the job and the resulting fee. It’s a simpler budgeting process for the Client. It’s YOUR problem if you underestimated the effort, not the Client’s problem.

Promote Your Services
There are so many avenues for this now. In-person events, social media posts, articles (like this one) on LinkedIn. (I prefer in-person events, but I’m my own worst enemy on that count. I am more likely to stay in-office and work on documentation.)

Build a Team You Know and Trust
As your business expands, establish and cultivate relationships with other SMEs. Be transparent in all business dealings, learn from your business partners (like my colleague Leslie Lupton), be generous and unquestioning on sharing the wealth. I’m lucky to be working with the same business partners for 15 – 20 years. There is no churn.

Costs and Benefits

Consider the costs associated with Consulting. Have you priced out the cost of self-employed health insurance? It’s probably as much as your home mortgage. Ours was around $2,300/month. And don’t forget insurance. Client contracts specify insurance requirements before you begin working with them. General business insurance and cyber insurance (if you are handling data) will probably add another $5K to your annual costs.

On the other hand, equipment (laptops, printers, etc.), supplies, justifiable travel, home office – those can all be potential write-offs at tax time.

If after reading all this, you are still excited about being a Consultant – go to it and good luck!

In the Early Days of AI

I am not a luddite. In fact, I am building AI tools to manage digital advertising. But I just have to say, we need to be a little less trusting when it comes to these early days in this technology.

Stay with me here because what seems to be trivial illustrates the potential for catastrophic results. Here’s a case in point.

I’m doing some research on my next car. I asked Google’ Gemini the following question:

—Doug: “What is the optimal lease deal on a Hyundai Ioniq 5 XRT?”

I received a pretty comprehensive response, which included the following statement

—Gemini: “Ensure the $7,500 EV lease bonus (Pass-through / HMF incentive) is fully applied to capitalize cost reduction.”

There is a big problem with that conclusion – the lease bonus does not exist. So, my response was:

—Doug: “You are out of date on your information. There is no federal $7,500 EV tax credit”

To which Gemini replied:

—Gemini “You are entirely correct, and I apologize for that oversight. The federal $7,500 EV tax credit was repealed under the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA) and officially ended for new purchases after September 30, 2025”

I was a little incredulous at this oversight, so I asked Gemini

—Doug: “Why didn’t you know this?”

Google’s rationale was:

—Gemini “I slipped back into an outdated baseline because my training history is heavily saturated with years of data detailing the original 2032 expiration date. When analyzing lease dynamics, my system initially defaulted to that historical “leasing loophole” framework instead of strictly locking into the current September 2026 reality.”

Here’s my issue with all this. This is a pretty poor level of analytics. If I applied this current level of technology to create the optimal media plan based on historical results, I don’t think my advertising client would be happy with the results.

Here’s my bigger issue with all this. If a government agency relied on this level of analytics, would it be any surprise if they used the resulting data to arrive at faulty policies, or misguided objectives?

Just saying. It’s early days here. Be vigilant in accepting conclusions at face value.

20+ Years of Ad Platform Deployments Have Taught Us This….

This post is for any Publisher engaged in the selection and deployment of an Ad Platform, whether it is a CRM, OMS, Ad Server, DMP, or Billing system. (If you are an Ad Platform, it wouldn’t hurt for you to read this as well)

Requirements are Key
Any selection of an Ad Platform must begin by documenting the Publisher’s business requirements. Without this knowledge, both Publisher and Ad Platform are operating in the dark and engaged in wishful thinking. Those requirements become the basis for RFP.

Knowledge Lives in Silos…Dig It Out.
The problem with requirements is that they live in silos. Ad Products, Pricing, Discounts, Inventory, Workflow, Trafficking – each of them may have an SME, but frequently, there is no single person who possesses knowledge of all these functions. As a precursor to vendor selection, it is contingent on the Publisher to dig those requirements out and bring them into the light of day.

Mind the Gaps
One of the most important functions of the RFP is to reveal gaps in the Ad Platforms’ ability to fulfill business requirements. Every Ad Platform will have feature gaps – they cannot realistically fulfill 100% of every requirement. That’s ok. The RFP answers a key Publisher question – which gaps can I live with and which are non-negotiable? Now you can make a knowledge-based decision on the Ad Platform.

Document Solutions
Is a gap non-negotiable? Negotiate a solution with the Ad Platform, then put it IN WRITING in the agreement with milestone dates. (Did you read the part about, “put it in writing?” Just making sure.) Now you have an agreement with an Ad Platform that fulfills most of your requirements out of the box and commits to developing the solutions that will close the gaps.

Their Timeline is Not Your Timeline
It’s great that the Ad Platform you selected can deploy and launch in 4 months. But that is THEIR timeline. What is YOURS as a Publisher? How much time does it take your legal and procurement team to negotiate a contract? Or the time your technology department needs to conduct a security review of the Ad Platform? Or the time that it takes your internal teams to “allocate resources” to this project? Just saying, the timeline is a two way street.

Define the Acceptance Criteria
You may be reaching the finish line on a deployment, but do you know if other stakeholders (finance, legal, technology) have an acceptance criteria of their own that will potentially add days or weeks of testing? Ask that question early.

Deployments are a big deal, engaging time and resources. These tips will help minimize surprises.

NO (as in “zero”) AI was used in the composition of this post. But I’m pretty sure this will be crawled, ingested, and repurposed from this point forward. Oh well.

What Publishers Need to Consider, When They Consider AI: Part 3 – Tag Validation and Creative Management

After exploring scenarios where AI could help Publishers manage media planning and inventory more efficiently (Parts 1 and 2), I wanted to apply some of the same thinking toward automating the submission of ad tags from Agencies through the validation and trafficking of those tags at the publisher.

The crude, admittedly “non-AI” illustration below illustrates the concept. . A validation (or filtration) module could be set up by the Publisher and configured with their criteria for acceptable ad specifications. Then, 1) the Agency submits the ad tag. 2) the Publisher has already configured the filter with their ad specs 3) the filter ingests the tag and tests against the Publisher specs. An auto confirmation of receipt and acceptance is sent back to the Agency. OR, an automated message explaining why the tag is not acceptable and recommendations for correcting and resubmitting it.

Finally, every Publisher should have the ability to use AI to automatically scan video content for compliance with their editorial standards. For example, classifying ads as political, gambling, adult – and rejecting them automatically if they all into those forbidden categories. This in fact, is being accomplished by vendor Integration X.

The objective would be to fully automate this part of the trafficking process from the time the Agency submits the tag to the time the Publisher traffics it.

What Publishers Need to Consider, When They Consider AI. Part 2: Inventory Forecasting

This document continues the discussion on how AI could influence end to end workflow in Revenue Operations. Part 1 covered Proposal Workflow.  Part 2 of this series examines Inventory Forecasting.

A couple of caveats.

  • This explores inventory forecasting’s impact on direct sales (including programmatic guaranteed) – but does NOT cover other programmatic buy types. I’m acknowledging that while programmatic may be the ultimate future for us all, direct sales is not dead yet. So how can we improve their use of inventory?
  • I want to acknowledge the industry contributions of Tom Shields who founded Yieldex, the platform that challenged the notion that publishers were chained to the limitations of GAM inventory forecasting.

What’s wrong with inventory forecasting today for direct sales? Are we discussing a problem that doesn’t exist? After all, GAM has a 24 month lookback at inventory, to help incorporate the impact of seasonality or events on availability. GAM has a manual inventory adjustment feature that allows publishers to “tweak” the forecast based on factors that may be unique to their domain.

But there is room for improvement. If programmatic has taught direct sales anything, it is that at scale, incremental changes in how inventory is managed can result in significant increases in revenue.

I think AI can play an important role here, by not only ingesting data that occurred in the past, but quantifying the impact that 1) real time events and 2) future events will have on inventory. Thus, providing more accurate data for proposals and campaign optimization.

Predictive Inventory Alerts

Perhaps direct sales can learn a lesson from programmatic. When there are unexpected spikes in ad inventory, programmatic is used for backfill, which is fully automated.

I don’t believe ad platforms do a good job of leveraging the data we can derive from CMS (content management) platforms such as page views, which correlate to ad impressions.

Perhaps we can use AI to intercept CMS data, analyze spikes in activities, and send an alert to a custom field in GAM which in essence says “hey, for the next 3 days, you can sell X% more inventory in the business/finance section”. An inventory manager could use that intel to engage with direct sales to sell the overflow.

Forecasting Based on Future Events

Depending on the publisher, here are some events that will take place in the future that could influence inventory forecasting:

  • Editorial features, scheduled throughout the year
  • Midterm Elections, national and local
  • Tentpole events, awards ceremonies
  • Retail promotions and seasonal influences
  • New product releases
  • Sporting events. Superbowl, FIFA, Olympics, etc. .
  • Weather events and seasonality

Combining this future facing data with historical lookbacks could provide a more intelligent inventory forecast. By training AI to ingest this large data set (or “corpus” as it is sometimes referred to), I think we’d have a better method of prediction.

Do we know what the 2026 midterm election will be on certain types of inventory? Do we have to do a “back of the envelope” guess to arrive at that number? We might get a more accurate reading if AI was able to combine historical lookbacks with the future events, unlocking the potential for more direct sold inventory.

Is all this wool gathering even worth it? Here’s an example.

A publisher with 150,000,000 sold ad imps / month @$25 cpm = $3,750,000 ad revenue

If the methods above yielded a15% uplift = $562,500 a month, or $6,750,000 per year.

Another $6MM a year through more effective inventory management would be worth it.

What Publishers Need to Consider, When They Consider AI. Part 1: Proposal Workflow

This is Part I in a series of discussions on the potential impact of AI solutions on workflow in Revenue Operations. Each part will explore one of the workflow stages, as depicted below.

The typical workflow for Publishers engaged in direct sales has stages that are co-dependent, like links in a chain.

For every process that incorporates AI there is a downstream (or upstream) implication.

It is important for Publishers to consider AI solutions, but context is important.

When considering incorporating AI, either through internal development, or use of an external vendor, or utilizing the existing OMS, there are several questions that need to be answered.

  • Will an AI solution decrease the steps required to execute an order, or increase them?
  • What are the implications on the rest of the workflow?
  • What is the cost in licensing and human capital (i.e. training and maintenance), and will the AI solution be enough to offset that cost?
  • Just because you can implement AI into your workflow, should you?

This is the first in a series of discussions on AI in Revenue Operations, starting with the RFP and Proposal stage, followed by analysis of the entire “quote to cash” process.

PART 1: Proposal Workflow

The “Legacy” Proposal Process

This process begins with an Agency RFP, delivered to the Salesperson, and handed off to the Media Planner (or similar title/function).

The bulk of this work falls on the Media Planner, who must take input from both Agency and Sales, and manually create media plans in response to the RFP. To do this, they need to consider:

  • Agency Targeting and Audience Requirements
  • Available inventory
  • Past pricing / discounts
  • Past performance for client
  • Past performance for others in category
  • Input from Sales

Compounding this manual work is the fact that Media Planning turnover is relatively high, so the institutional knowledge is lost, requiring each new Media Planner to accumulate this data all over again.

Furthermore, the Agency RFP may include a specific template with built in macros which the Planner is required to fill out manually.

The friction in this process is the manual labor required to create and deliver media plans in response to the Agency RFP.

Here’s a graphic representation of how the Proposal Workflow, without AI, works today .

Future Proposal Process – AI Enabled

What can AI do for the publisher to improve the legacy workflow as depicted above?

AI can automate all processes from the time the Salesperson receives the RFP, to the time an approved media plan is signed by the Agency, staged in the OMS and ready for trafficking.

Some OMS platforms, as well as stand-alone AI platforms include some, but not all, of the features described in the following pages.

Specifically, we can look for AI to:

Ingest Agency RFP from Sales

  • Agency RFP document
  • Qualitative and Quantitative KPIs from Agency
  • Targeting requirements
  • Budget requirements
  • Additional data from Sales using AI Agent prompts

Perform Historical Data Analysis to Inform the Agency RFP

  • Agency buying patterns and preferences
  • Past pricing / discounts
  • Past performance for client
  • Past performance for others in category

Output the Media Plans

  • Multiple media plans if required by Agency
  • Routed through internal pricing and inventory checks. (This is standard OMS functionality)
  • Automatically revised in response to internal pricing and inventory guidelines.
  • Output in the Agency template (complete with macros)
  • Sent to Sales and Agency
  • AI executes revisions as requested by the Agency and returns to Agency as a revised response to the RFP.

Taking these features into account, here is an example of what a fully featured AI –  enabled workflow looks like in support of the Proposal process at the Publisher:

What are the benefits of the AI – enabled approach?

  • Dramatic reduction in the LOE and response time required to respond to RFPs and subsequent revisions
  • Enable media planners to supervise more Agency relationships, without an increase in internal resources.

Three Potential Scenarios for Implementing AI-enabled Proposal Workflow

There are 3 scenarios for incorporating AI into the proposal process workflow.

Scenario 1:

A new AI proposal building app from a third party is incorporated into the workflow and the Publisher’s ad stack.

  • The new app may have been created “from the ground up” to inject AI into the proposal building process, and may be taking advantage of the latest developments in that technology
    • The new app will require integration into Salesforce and the existing OMS
    • The new app will require implementation, license fees, training and personnel.

Scenario 1 Summary

This is a fast track implementation of AI. But increased fees and a high LOE for integrations and human capital will be required to sustain the application. This may (or may not) be offset by the reduced workload for media planners.

Scenario 2:

AI functionality for proposal workflow is built into the existing OMS.

  • The OMS includes AI functionality for proposal workflow
    • Integrations with Salesforce (or other CRM) remain intact.
    • Marginal (if any) increase in fees, training and personnel
    • OMS adoption of AI brings the Publisher into the AI space, in a modulated fashion – which separates what is critical from a feature standpoint from what may be unwanted “noise”
    • The AI solution offered by the OMS may be just one of many features that need to be supported and may (or may not) keep up with AI centric proposal workflow application.

Scenario 2 Summary

A more modulated approach to AI adoption. AI development by the OMS will be interwoven with other features in the platform, and more likely to take into consideration the entire end to end workflow. Plus, lower LOE for the Publisher.

Scenario 3:

Internal Publisher Development is used to Incorporate AI into the Proposal Workflow. 

A classic build-versus buy scenario.

  • Publisher can create bespoke AI solutions for automating proposal workflow
    • Out of pocket costs are internal resources
      • This is a “heavy lift” in terms of LOE, which must be supported for years by dedicated, internal publisher resources.
      • Historically, internal development teams are difficult to maintain and may not be nimble enough to stay abreast of industry changes in media.
      • Calls into question if the core business of the Publisher is software development, or content.  

Scenario 3 Summary

The “build” scenario for AI – enabled proposal workflow requires a huge, lengthy commitment in time and internal resources

Summary

Publishers will eventually be adopting some degree of AI to improve proposal workflow.

Revenue Operations should take a proactive lead in defining how AI will be incorporated into workflow.

The options for engaging resources to onboard AI include leveraging your existing OMS, engage with a new third party AI platform, or developing an AI platform in-house.

The decision points for adopting AI for Publishers include the following:

  • Net reduction of workflow steps, and avoiding breakage upstream or down
  • Total cost of ownership (license + integration + human capital)
  • Integration with CRM, OMS, GAM, and programmatic platforms
  • Governance + compliance requirements
  • Impact on staffing and roles

Part II on this discussion will explore how the Inventory forecasting and management process can be enhanced through AI. Coming Soon!

Regards, Doug Wintz

2025 in Revenue Operations and a Prediction for 2026: “FOMO meets Reality Check”


Recapping 2025, a year that was filled with significant projects for Conde Nast, Wall Street Journal, NewsCorp, WebMD, New England Journal of Medicine and Chartbeat. The work spanned 8 countries across North America, South America, UK, Europe (Italy, France, Germany, Spain) and the Middle East. The platforms included CRM, OMS, Ad Serving, BI, Billing and AI. The scope of work included managing the RFP process, project management for deployment of new platforms, configuration, ETL work for data migrations, testing and training.

Moving forward, we think 2026 will be an atypical year for one singular reason. No surprise that it is centered around AI.

“FOMO* meets Reality Check”.

In 2026 +, the headline for publishers (and agencies) will be “FOMO meets Reality Check”. Revenue Operations professionals will be examining AI driven solutions because they will be compelled to by their management and their peers. They will need to consider the following when it comes to AI-enabled platforms supporting sales and media operations:

Are the benefits of the AI solution confined to single aspect of workflow, such as media planning?

Is the vendor’s AI solution fully developed, with a track record of supporting major clients? Or is it a work in progress?

Can KPI’s be defined to determine the effectiveness the AI solution, as it becomes integrated into the ad stack?

Will the addition of an AI enabled platform increase operational efficiency, or will it add yet another series of steps on top of the existing end to end workflow?

How will data produced by the AI platform be integrated into existing business intelligence platforms?

How will the AI solution be integrated with existing platforms (CRM, Ad Serving, etc.)?

There will be significant benefits from AI over the course of time. But for the short terms, we expect Publishers and Agencies to spend a good amount of time defining exactly where and how it is incorporated in their end-to-end workflow. Of course, we can help with this.

Happy Holidays and looking forward to an exciting New Year.

Doug Wintz
www.dmwmediablog.com
www.dmwmediaworks.com

*FOMO = Fear of Missing Out”

(AI was NOT used in the composition of this post)

Here’s Looking at Your Future, Kid

Here’s Looking at Your Future, Kid
Originally published in IMediaConnection. October 17, 2005

Doug Wintz travels to 2020 to see how today’s dysfunctional mediascape will evolve into a sophisticated real-time trading marketplace.

Technology gives birth to applications that measure activity
and make decisions at an increasingly accelerated pace. Examples are numerous, ranging from the computer in your car that regulates engine performance, braking and passive safety systems, to the systems that drive the financial markets of the NYSE and NASDAQ.

As these systems are introduced, they change the way businesses are structured, create the need for new skill sets and force companies to rethink how they approach traditional markets.

The media business is not exempt from this effect. Measuring online activity is
becoming more sophisticated. As this trend continues the traditional roles of
marketing directors, media planners, buyers, media operations execs and staffers will change.

The following is a look at an alternative future that might be the result of these changes to our business.

Welcome to the year 2020

At 6:00AM on May 4, of 2020, Toshiko Jones took the elevator down to the
ground floor of her residence and waited patiently for her car service. While she waited, she surveyed the horizon of lush green mangroves on one side and an expanse of placid, slate-grey ocean on the other. Her Gulf Coast home was located in an exclusive development, a retreat occupied by the elite and wealthy.

Toshiko could afford it. Her firm, Media Asset Management (MAM), handled the purchasing and distribution of advertising for the top 10 corporations in the United States. She was one of a handful of individuals with expertise in the real-time purchase, placement, optimization and measurement of multi-media campaigns. The roles of the media planner, buyer, trafficker and marketing manager had converged into a new function — a Media Asset Manager.

Like the most prestigious financial asset management firms of the past (Fidelity, SmithBarney, et al), media asset firms now had corporate clients who entrusted them with exorbitant budgets and relied on them to generate the highest return on their investments. So MAM was responsible for buying, selling and placing media on a minute by minute basis across all media channels including Vidline, Satradio and Print.

Even conservative clients who balked at this model eventually saw the value in
granting a company or individual the aggregated responsibility and authority to plan, buy, sell, traffic, measure and optimize media in the same way that stock portfolios were managed.

After all, it was done real-time now. Companies who insisted on giving their
permission on each and every aspect of media buys and placement quickly found that they didn’t have the time, attention or expertise to evaluate and optimize every five minutes. Companies who refused to get in the game found that their brand, their sales and their futures where outflanked by competitors who felt perfectly comfortable letting control freaks like Toshiko and MAM take the reigns
of their media budgets.

Toshiko grabbed a handful of jet black hair, pushed it away from her neck and
held it for a moment. The sea breeze was warm, and heavy with humidity. She
heard the whir of the hybrid from the frontage road, anticipating the arrival of the limousine. She let her hair fall and collected her bags, eager as always to make the trip to New York and present her media strategy to a new prospect — in this case, Danbury Genetic Enhancements.

As she often did, she reflected during the outbound trip on events that took her from being a simple ad trafficker to CEO of MAM — a company that leveraged the enormous change in media to achieve a valuation that rivaled old school edifices like Chase, Microsoft and Google. Again, the same question arose in her mind…

The past evolves into the future

How did the dysfunctional mediascape of 2005 evolve so rapidly into a real-time marketplace whose sophistication in trading rivaled the New York Stock
Exchange?

After all, 2005, the media landscape was a mess. A large corporation could look forward to working with a creative agency, a media buying agency, an interactive agency, a direct marketing agency. Yes, yes, there were large global agencies who gave the appearance of doing it all, but at best their internal divisions seldom knew what each other was doing. At worse, the agency was a virtually a shell that outsourced to dozens of independents.

In 2005, the operations landscape fared no better. You could expect to traffic
scores of creative files and equal number of media outlets. Video was sent to
broadcast companies. Audio to radio. Gifs and rich media to hundreds of
websites. Bluelines were messengered back and forth to print vendors.

The change for the better was precipitated by the following breakthroughs that took place over the last fifteen years:

• Broadcast, online, ecommerce and direct marketing were consolidated
into a single subscriber service dubbed “Vidline.” This was the realization
of convergence. The old-style TV went the way of the eight-track. The PC
as a stand-alone device fared only slightly better — it was used by the
same types of curmudgeonly Luddites who once said the CD would never
replace the cassette deck.

• Media operations converged into a single application that supporting all
media, brought about by the rollup of companies who once were focused
exclusively on ad serving, or video content management, or email
distribution, or audio, or ecommerce transactions, or print. A single
application now handled that distribution and reporting task across all
media. Toshiko’s MAM was one of three companies who accomplished the
rollup of these operational functions.

• Buying media gradually changed from a process that focused on a largely
manual process of matching audience with programming, to a real-time
trading exchange whose buyers and sellers could shift media dollars on a
minute by minute basis, depending on their goals in branding, cost per
lead, ecommerce, et cetera. Up-front buys still existed, but the basis for
negotiation had adapted to the changing marketplace.

• Measurement of branding effectiveness was now real-time. The creation
of the Rickert Branding Scale gave companies like Toshiko’s the ability to
gauge not only the direct response aspects of media, but the branding
effectiveness as well and with the same real-time reporting. The
methodology included measuring the number of subscribers who viewed
the commercial messages, the potential number of family members
viewing, the duration and attention paid to the message, and their value to
the product in terms their demographics. It was a kind of EKG for the
brand.

Lost in thought and reflection, the time passed quickly and
Toshiko found herself at her destination at 53rd and Park.
The old Lever Brothers building still had an elegance that enabled it to withstand the test of time. The fact that Danbury Genetic chose it for the corporate headquarters was, perhaps, a good omen.


The presentation was held in the boardroom — a massive room that seemed out of proportion to the total number of attendees. Rice Hopkins, CEO and Heather Williams, SVP of Marketing were the attendees, both seated at the head of a rich, mahogany conference table. Toshiko positioned herself a couple of seats away. Close enough that she could still see her audience, far enough to establish a distance that hinted at the exclusive expertise she brought to the table.

“Toshiko, thanks for your time,” began Rice. “We’ve had a lot of discussions and I see this as the decision making meeting. To recap, we’re old school when it comes to marketing. In the past we’ve exercised a lot of control. We use agencies who present the creative ideas, separate media groups that present strategy and tell us where, when and how our name will be presented. We really can’t assess the results until well after a flight has concluded. It’s a very hands-on process that, frankly, is time intensive and manual”

“As we’ve discussed, Mr. Hopkins, that eats a lot of your time,” Toshiko said.
“True enough,” he said. “But it’s hard to give up control. Part of that is me; part of it is our product. We engineer genetic changes in utero for parents who want to customize their kid the same way their grandparents customized their cars. All of our marketing is heavily regulated by Federal guidelines, and we ourselves have to make sure our claims are balanced with disclosure on the risks.”

“Understood,” Toshiko said. “And that’s one area we don’t want to get involved in — the creative.” [2025 edit by Doug Wintz – yeah, and even creative is now automated by AI, so my future self sees I missed that as a forecast.]

“Listen, can we cut to the chase?” Heather asked. She shifted in her chair with
visible impatience. Toshiko couldn’t blame her. Heather was about to cede control of a valuable marketing function. Her role would be diminished. Rice gave her a good glare, and then nodded at Toshiko.

The media maven as media trader

Toshiko plugged in her laptop, toggled the display so that the MAM Control
Screen filled up the 8 x 6 foot flat screen at the end of the conference room.
“Great. Let’s go.” Toshiko rose to her feet. She always felt better presenting on
her feet, pacing and gesturing to stress her points. “You’ve given me a test budget of $250,000 to prove that MAM can do better than your traditional methods. You would spend that money anyway, and it’s a fraction of the $75 million you’ll spend on various media this year. It’s a small price to pay for a test that will change the way you do business forever. So, I’m going to take that money and invest it now in your vidline schedule. It’s 5:45 PM now, and over the next couple of hours we’ll put that money to work for you.”

“As you can see, I’ve taken the money and allocated it to the traditional media you currently use. See the tab marked ‘vidline’? You’ll see there are placements that are scheduled for 6 PM airing — two minutes from now — across NewsCorp, GoogleVision, YaNews and BBC.” She let it sink in. “In sixty seconds, we’re going to view the initial results of those placements.”

Toshiko focused on the media dashboard. Selecting the “vidline” tab transformed the screen into a series of four separate grids, one for each distribution channel. In the corner of each grid, a bar pulsated as if waiting for something to happen. At 5:59, something did. Toshiko click on a rapidly flashing, blue asterisk labeled “Distribute” and at once each grid sprang to life filling the screen with bars and lines that took on a life of their own.

Toshiko’s expert eyes translated the activity in an instant and she narrated for
Rice and Heather. “We just distributed your creative to the four target networks and now we’re viewing the responses to your marketing campaigns. We can measure the response to your video commercial by counting the requests for additional downloaded information packets as well as increases in your call center activity. In addition, the line traveling along the “y” axis shows the changes to the Rickert Branding Scale.”

“Let’s see what the impact is from these first placements,” she continued. The
NewsCorp placements have done extremely well, generating 25 percent more
leads and increasing the Rickert Scale from the baseline by 35 percent. That’s a relatively high index for your category and product — and it means that both response and branding have increased. But the YaNews placement really
bombed. Let’s see why… ah… they’re promoting the Amor Awards with graphic video segments. No wonder the attention is off your product. Nice of them to keep that programming change a secret.”

“So, what do we do? I want to sell your YaNews flight on the open spot market. Someone will snatch it up with a product that is a better fit for the programming. Let’s heavy up on the NewsCorp placements by trading or purchasing on same media marketplace and see the effect. I’ve initiated that change now. Next placement airs in five, four, three, two, one.”
And so it went for the next hour. On a minute by minute basis, Toshiko shifted the balance and placement of media in reaction the performance of each distribution channel. Both the increase in the Rickert Scale for branding and the actual response were important. Sometimes the change in a broadcaster’s programming influenced results, sometimes a local breaking news story diverted a metro population’s attention, necessitating a shift of media to an adjacent market. Changes in distribution material could be made as well, by sending subtle changes to brochures or telemarketing scripts electronically. Thus, conversion could be impacted as well.

The demonstration came to an end. Toshiko took her hands off the keyboard,
wiped her brow with the back of her shirtsleeve and faced her prospects, letting it all sink in.

“Well, what did that prove?” spoke Heather. Toshiko couldn’t have set it up any better if she supplied Heather with the script.

“Good question, and here’s the answer,” said Toshiko as she toggled the screen display. “You’re now looking at two screens. The first screen shows the projected results of your marketing campaign if you had allowed the placements to go on unchanged over the course of a full week. At best, results flatlined, and in general, their effectiveness diminished over time. The second screen shows the projection given MAM’s active management of your media assets. In just the first hour alone, we increased the Rickert Scale by 45 percent over traditional static placement and increased measurable response by 25 percent. Put into numbers, we just generated an additional $500,000 in leads and projected sales for your services in the one hour I’ve been sitting here.”

“So,” summarized Toshiko, “you can either continue to do things old school and have your competition overrun you, or you can give up control and let the experts in media buying, distribution and operations actively manage your account on a minute by minute basis. You give up your financial assets to SmithBarneyWatch –you’d be just as smart to give your media assets up to MAM.”

And with that, Toshiko closed the display and calmly stared at her newest clients.

So is this science fiction or science future?

I believe this is a plausible future. The internet has driven a measurement
revolution in media that won’t go away. As media converges, that same
accountability will become as much a part of the traditional vernacular as GRPs are today. Decision making will be fast and furious, and — like the fund managers who manipulate stock portfolios today — a new class of experts will be responsible for getting the best yield out of a media budget.

Minute-by-minute.


Hour-by-hour.


Day-by-day.

Making Branded Content a Seamless Process Through AI

We are so close, yet so far from the efficient management of large-scale branded content campaigns. Several companies provide the capability to create the media plan, traffic digital assets, extract digital performance data from both on-site and off-site (social media) placements and consolidate reporting on those elements.

But a major, branded content, cross-media campaign for a Tier 1 client encompasses so much. Several improvements are necessary in order to create a single entry point for the creation, management and reporting of all branded content elements and AI could definitely play a role.

This does not have to be a nightmare of coordination between a publishers marketing and and operations groups. Ideally, it is all centralized within the publishers OMS.

These include the following features:

Project planning and coordination, enabled by AI, all within the OMS because there are so many elements that today need to be tracked as separate processes.

When custom creative is required, set the due dates for each step leading to the completion of production-ready creative assets  

If talent is involved, include the timeline for choosing and licensing that content.

AI can create the plan, showing the explicit start date and due dates for all elements of the branded campaign across all media and production, online and offline.

Designate who needs to approve each element of the campaign and who needs to be notified.

Real-time optimization triggered by the KPIs for each line item.

A graphic with all the elements is below.

All of this is within the realm of possibility for an AI enabled module within the OMS.

As publishers seek to deliver more value to their major advertising clients, they will need in internal process that is centralized, coordinated and managed from a single OMS module.

For Publishers, AI is a Slippery Bar of Soap

There is no doubt that AI is transformative. In sales and ad operations, it has the potential to reduce or even eliminate the friction that is part of the everyday process of getting a campaign from quote to cash.

However, there are some limitations. And it’s less about the technical limitations and more about the limitations imposed by human beings.

We can break out the potential benefits that AI could offer for a publisher’s direct sales and ad operations as follows:

SLAM DUNK

Media planning

AI vendors have already introduced the ability to automatically create proposals and media plans, which are informed instantaneously by historical results for that particular client, and can help predict the optimum plan moving forward.

STRETCH GOALS

Workflow

Designing and optimizing workflow, including approval processes, user roles and permissions, could all be streamlined by AI. Ingest a publisher’s current workflow and make recommendations for improvement and even configure the optimal workflow in the OMS.

Ad Product Taxonomy

Similar to the potential improvement above, AI could translate a publisher’s current taxonomy and make recommendations for improvement which could include making a product catalogue more “findable” for proposals and more efficient for inventory management and trafficking.

Inventory forecasting

I would hope that AI can do a better job of forecasting than the tools we use today. This could include a stronger link to the real time performance of content, which has a real time impact on advertising inventory. Additionally, creating forecasting that is instantaneously linked to historical inventory trends from seasonal and tentpole events would increase accuracy.

Optimization

Automating the optimization of direct sold campaigns and recommending improvements would be a boon for inventory managers. The “stretch” in this goal is the need to manually confer with an advertising client and obtaining their approval for the changes in an optimized campaign, or setting up the permission beforehand to make changes on the fly.

Salesforce.

Any AI solution that hopes to create a single point of entry to manage the quote to cash process is going to have to navigate around Salesforce. In some cases, adding yet another application between the CRM and OMS will be a hurdle. In other cases, proposing to replace SF with a new AI enable solution which would be truly end to end will run into the need for sales to cling to their current CRM.

BLOCKERS

Third party ad tags

If every ad tag received by an agency was 100% functional, this would not be an issue. However, it’s not the case. AI “could” ingest, process and traffic ad tags automatically. But because there are human operators on both sides, the troubleshooting process will continue to be manual. This is a blocker for an AI enabled trafficking process.

Billing and Invoicing

If every campaign billed on publisher delivery numbers, this would not be an issue. However, it’s not the case. Every billing cycle is an exercise in verifying the invoice reflects the ad agency’s delivery numbers. There is a highly manual verification exercise that takes place each billing cycle, to the extent that the “real” accounting is not locked down for several days. This is a blocker for an AI module that would allow invoicing at the touch of a button.

In summary, I think that AI can do sales and ad operations a world of good, but the barriers to entry will be less about the technology, and more about legacy processes, institutions, and of course, people.